HOVZ Stock Market Forecasts

April 13, 2008
On track for more rebound?

All HOVZ Archived Commentary
Links to Other Stock Market Indicators

The short term view of the stock market still looks pretty good. Sure, the overall economy is still headed downhill, and the credit bubble still needs to deflate.. Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers says: "From the perspective of Main Street and the real economy, there is a large amount of pain left to be felt." And the IMF has concluded that total losses, including securities tied to commercial real estate and consumer and corporate loans may reach $945 billion -- way above their earlier estimates. None of this is very cheery.

But, the stock market operates on its own forward-looking logic and is recovering a bit because the nightmare scenario of a complete financial market collapse did not occur. (Yet.) As Todd Harrison's Minyanville article "35 signs that the market hasn't bottomed out yet" says, the "March lows were an excellent trading opportunity but not the ultimate bottom."

Over the last half-year the HOVZ Market Enthusiasm Indicator has been showing aharply falling investor optimism that may well have formed a double bottom. For some time the indicator has pointed (prematurely) to a significant but temporary rebound. Financial panic attacks always have a unique cause, but they all play out the same. Take a look at the long term history of the HOVZ Market Enthusiasm Indicator .

Now, many other popular indicators like the slow stochastic oscillator and NYSE New Highs & New Lows , and the Morningstar.Com Market Valuation graph  are showing the same basic picture.

Even bad looks good in the view of contrarians. Most consumer confidence and investor sentiment indicators are very low as in this one from the Pew Research Center. These sentiment indicators tend to be modestly good contrarian indicators. Likewise, leading economic indicators are all down-- which tends to be a positive contrarian indicator in Mark Hulbert's contrarian view

Likewise, some popular market commentators are changing their tunes. Here is a piece from three weeks ago by Jon Markman from MSN MoneyCentral writing "Sell while the selling is good!" Then more recently he said : "... I am happy to reconsider my blanket sell recommendation as the threat has likely passed."

Here are a few other articles defusing panic. Robert Samuelson at WashingtonPost.com saying: "hold the hysteria." Tobias Levkovich reckoning a 92% chance stocks will rise in the next 6 months. George Soros (Bloomberg) expecting a significant bounce for a few months followed be more market deterioration.

I see it, the market bounce should only be temporary because the real economy still faces major economic distortions that remain to be worked out -- not over the next few weeks, but over the next few years.

1, Housing affordability must readjust to normal levels
Over several years, the speculative housing bubble took house prices way above their normal relation to incomes (a relationship that has been amazingly consistent for many countries over decades). Several estimates say that house prices need to fall back to roughly 2004 levels, a reduction of about 20%.to 30%. Both homeowners and lenders will be hit by this readjustment. This huge drop in wealth has only started to impact the economy. A large number of teaser-rate subprime mortgages still are facing reset over the next two years. Just considering the resulting decline in consumer spending implies that the growth rate of corporate profits is near-certain to fall for a considerable amount of time putting pressure on stock P/E multiples.

2. Losses must be absorbed and insolvencies avoided
As reported in The Economist, Goldman Sachs now estimates that the direct impact of a 25% reduction of home prices will eventually reach over $1.1 trillion, about 8% of GDP, or something like 3 years of normal GDP growth. That's pretty bad -- perhaps 8.8 million homeowners may find themselves financially underwater. Further losses in the stock market would only make things worse. But, far more serious to the integrity of the financial system is the probable loss to U.S. financial firms of about $300 billion, just over 2% of GDP. That capital now is used as margin reserve by these financial firms to justify highly leveraged borrowing. Assuming rather low leverage of just 10-to-1, the loss of $300 billion capital must either be replaced by new investors (e.g. overseas sovereign wealth funds) or loans of roughly $3 trillion would need to be called in -- something in the order of 20% of GDP. Whatever the outcome, it is sure that credit will be tight, impacts will continue to spread, and more insolvency fears and bad news will continue to flow for years. The days of loose credit are gone for a while.

3, U.S. Current Account must get closer to balance
Following the rising value of the dollar under the Clinton administration, the U.S. balance of payments -- which had been bad already -- went totally out of whack during the Bush years. The flow of dollars to buy oil and way too many goods abroad got out of hand -- nearly 6% of GDP on an annual basis. The Bush administration decided to let the invisible hand of the market solve the huge U.S. current account deficit. i.e. They inflated the dollar. With enough reduction in value of the dollar, eventually the foreign trade deficit would self correct. When Bush came into power a Euro cost about $1.00. Now a Euro costs about $1.55. Despite this huge change the current account balance has only improved slightly. The dollar is probably going to fall more. So the wealth of Americans and all those holding dollars will go down. It also makes it less likely that foreign capital will be investing in the the U.S.. The positive side of this is increasingly it should help profits of companies making money outside the U.S..

4, Foreign stock market and worldwide commodity price bubbles must subside
In 2000 a gallon of gasoline cost about $0.96. Now it costs about $3.40. That is an increase that is far in excess of the impact caused by a falling dollar. While there are several factors behind the increase in commodity prices, especially fear premiums for oil and increasing worldwide demand for other commodities, some of the increase is a speculative bubble. The bubble has been pervasive, the same sort of increase has occurred with many other commodities such as gold. The charts in this Barrons article are striking. The flight of capital to the supposed 'safe haven' of commodities has created a major bubble. Similarly, stock markets in a number of countries such as China and India have been showing rampant speculation. As confidence comes back to the financial markets and as recession causes demand to subside, the commodities markets and bubbled stock markets might well implode. The China stock market bubble (NYTimes.com) seems to be collapsing already .

Bottom line:  HOVZ Market Enthusiasm Indicator had been in free fall. It bottomed, rose considerably and has now retested the lows. We think many parts of the market are probably heading back up. Reinvesting for the next half-year is very attractive. (But not in the cyclical stocks of financials, real estate, discretionary items, or construction.) Every day the odds keep improving. Compared to October, many great stocks are now at 20% to 30% off sale prices! We now have a 100% investment level -- but humbly we admit to having jumped back in too fast and to have lost money as a result.

.(This column is not investment advice, YOU need to figure out what's best for you.)

Links to Other Stock Market Indicators We tend to focus our market timing attention on the HOVZ Market Enthusiasm Indicator which follows a roughly annual cycle. Several other popular market indicators are listed below.  

Morningstar.Com Market Valuation graph  (Shows market to be 13% undervalued -- much improved from 15% two weeks ago. Hopefully the market is completing a typical retesting of lows. There may be a huge stock market bubble somewhere -- but it isn't in the bulk of U.S. stocks that Morningstar tracks.) This graph is a fundamental financial analysis / accounting calculation based on long-term projected returns for the 1,800 stocks Morningstar tracks.  Typically in the past couple of years the trend has gone from undervalued to somewhat overvalued at 5% to 10%. But a 20%+ under pricing as in 2001 and 2002 is quite possible.

% Stocks Trading Above 200-Day Moving Average (The current value is shown at the very bottom of the link page. ) About 27% of stocks are above their 200-day average. Two weeks ago it was 17%, probably a bottom. It is still VERY LOW. As a general rule, when a stock's price is above its 200-day moving average, the stock is in a long-term price rise. So, an increasing percentage of stocks priced above their 200-day moving average is generally a good sign. However, when 80% to 90% of stocks are trading above their averages it is usually a signal that euphoria has gotten out of hand and a market correction is due. Similarly, when only 20% to 30% of stocks are trading above average (like now), a sharp bullish upswing becomes very likely It's your call as to whether the market will fall more. ( For someone with a long term perspective, the market is already in buying territory.)

NYSE New Highs & New Lows  Now at what is typically a good level for buying. The graph of new lows tracks fairly closely with our HOVZ Market Enthusiasm Indicator.  A 'Buy' indicator occurs when the number of Low values falls from a peak and a 'Sell' indicator occurs near when the number of new Highs peaks. www .InvestmentTools.com. 

Long Treasury Bond versus Discount Rate  High and/or rising interest rates tend to be bad for corporate profits and stock market prices. The Fed has dramatically lowered short term lending rates and clearly intends to use this stimulus to keep the economy pumped up. Unfortunately, it takes time for this stimulus to start working through the real economy and there is a major concern that moving rates too low could cause the value of the U.S. dollar to go into free fall. The rate inversion that existed most of last year ended up being a good predictor of the market troubles that are occurring right now. The question now is whether the Fed will lower rates as fast as the market wants. So far, that's exactly what the Fed has done.

Short Interest Ratio (from InvestmentTools.com) IGNORE THIS GRAPH -- It looks like incorrect weekly data Back near an all-time high. This has proven to be a good short range market predictor over the past year -- doesn't look good for the next few weeks. This number derived from NYSE data is the dollar value of total outstanding short positions divided by the value of an average day of trading -- essentially, how many days would it take to close all short positions. The last time the ratio was anywhere near this high was at the broad stock market top of 1998-1999. But it is WAY above that level now! Watch the moving average of this indicator for a very broad look at the anxiety level of the stock market.

Margin Debt  (The incredibly high level of margin debt is at least partially a sign of high leverage in the markets. The fact that the growth rate has fallen for months may be a sign of a longer term deleveraging. In the last bear market this was probably the BEST OVERALL INDICATOR for watching the bear run its course.) People who borrow money to buy stock (i.e. "buying on margin") fall into two groups. First, they might be optimists, convinced that the market is going up. On the other hand they can be hedgers, confident that they can borrow money to go long on 'winners' and short 'losers.' A rising level of margin is a good sign of a confident Bull market.  A persistently falling margin level is a clear sign of a Bear market -- the optimists get frightened and the hedgers flee the scene.

This chart from www.InvestmentTools.com shows that for the past few years we have been is a very strong period of rising margin, possibly too strong. The total amount of margin borrowing has surpassed the historic high reached in 2000. Start to pay attention to the rate-of-change graph at the bottom of the linked page. When the rate of change turns negative it will almost certainly mean a serious bear market. 

At the same time, it would probably be wrong to read too much into the predictive powers of margin debt levels according to this Mark Hulbert column from MarketWatch.com. Here is the NYSE data link.

Building Permits and Housing Starts (Major negative factor seldom worse than it is right now). Housing related activity -- not just construction, but including all factors such as new appliances -- constitutes roughly 20% to 25% of the U.S. economy, so it is much too big to ignore. These linked charts from the St. Louis Federal Reserve provide a way to watch the slow moving collapse unfold. Housing tends to lead the stock market by approximately one year. If so, that is very bad news. Each month the news just keeps getting worse. Here is a Wikipedia background piece on the U.S. Housing Bubble

U.S. Leading Economic Indicator  (See graph at bottom of link page.) (The leading indicator dropped again in February -- some big surprise? ) The link is from e-Forecasting.com. Since the stock market is itself a big component of composite leading economic indicators, it's questionable how much this can really tell you about what is going to happen next in the market. A competing an better known leading indicator, the Conference Board Leading Economic Indicator fell in February for the fourth straight month. Here's a Bloomberg story on it.

Anxious Index (xls file) (Long term negative) This article by David Leonhardt in the NY Times says the Index now points toward an economic recession. He notes this Survey of Professional Forecasters maintained by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve hasn't missed calling a recession or called a false positive in the years since 1968 when it was started. Updated quarterly.

U.S. Federal Deficit (from St. Louis Federal Reserve) Be careful what you wish for! To recover from the Dot Com market crash and the 2001 recession the Federal Government spent lavishly. The deficit moved from a $200 B per year surplus to a $400+ B deficit -- a net difference of roughly 1/2 trillion dollars per year. Not chump change. This is the economic 800 pound gorilla that caused the U.S. dollar to plummet over the past few years. Now, in a major turn-around, the deficit is rapidly declining. It is already $200 B per year better than a couple of years ago. Wrapping up the Iraq war could make another huge cut in federal spending. This week they decided to refill the punch bowl. The deficit is going to go up again. The loser will be the value of the dollar. For the moment, the reduction in the deficit is a significant contributor to the slowing economy. The federal $170 billion stimulus package that became law will not impact the economy for several months.

Effective Federal Funds Rate and Target Interest Rate (from St. Louis Federal Reserve) Negative The Fed has rushed like it never has before to drop short-term rates. At 2.25% there is not much further they can go. Eventually this will stimulate the economy. But, because of lag times, for now it is a major contrary signal showing just how worried they are at the Fed. The current MarketWatch.com forecast of interest rates points toward further rate cuts.

Price / Earnings Ratio of the SP-500  (To us this does not indicate a significantly overvalued market.) Except during short and intense recessions the composite P/E ratio of major corporations provides a general indication if the stock market is priced high or low. If this turns up, it probably will be a sign that earnings (right now at historically high levels) have gone to hell. That was much of the story in the 2002 rise of this indicator.

Supermarket Tabloid Indicator (Tabloids are screaming panic, a significant contrarian indicator.) Clif Droke at FinancialSense.com proposes Supermarket Tabloids as a contrarian indicator. Droke argues: "A sure sign that a trend has exhausted itself is when news tabloids start printing stories about economic depression and forecasting stock market crashes."  Well, that's where the market is right now.

Big Mac Index Economist.com has a truly wonderful (though perhaps not statistically definitive) means to spot if various currencies are reasonably valued against the U.S. dollar. It's based on the price of a Big Mac in each country. Right now the european countries appear to be overvalued. We're hoping this will tell us where we can afford to take our next foreign vacation.